Thai Black, Purple Rice Pudding with Coconut Cream Topping and Turandot

The story of Turandot has been on my mind so much these past few days that the thought of it has unfortunately interfered with my daily activities including cooking. I annoy myself to death sometimes. There seems to be something about Puccini that makes me susceptible to developing split personalities. Take, for instance, La Bohème. While the romantic and sappy part of me never fails to tear and choke up during Act 3 when Rudolfo confesses to Marcello the real reason why he has acted unkindly to Mimi, the cynic in me rolls her eyes and groans audibly every time she hears the cutesy Sì, mi chiamano Mimì. Last week, three hours of Turandot brought out the two personalities again.

Princess Turandot is often referred to as one of the most-hated opera characters, and that is for a very good reason. Seriously, what kind of witch comes up with a dumb rule that says she’s only going to marry only a suitor who can solve her three dumb riddles and that any who attempts and fails will part way with his head? Good thing the princess has the kind of beauty that makes even dead suitors cry out for her from the grave (dang …) as that seems to be the only asset the crazy broad has got going for her. She abhors all men because of one heinous crime committed by one man on one ancestress of hers. What is that about? I mean, a few years back I must have drunk half a bottle of Pepto-Bismol and spent one whole night bowing down to the porcelain god, whimpering in pain because of one bad char siu bao. But if anyone thinks I’ve sworn off all steamed Chinese filled buns, they’re seriously mistaken.

But while the cynic in me looks upon the Chinese princess with derision, the incurable romantic is able to see the redemptive quality she has demonstrated. You see, if you look a bit more closely, it’s not hatred that has caused Turandot to not only build impenetrable walls around her heart but also seek to exercise her royal power by stipulating death for any man who tries to conquer her; it’s fear.

Fear is a very powerful emotion, so powerful that it makes us freeze and procrastinate when there’s every reason to take action, quit when there’s every reason to continue, flee when there’s every reason to stay, and deny ourselves the soul-nourishing things our deepest part yearns for. Fear writes all the CANNOTs in uppercase and puts all the cans in the smallest available font size. Love or sorrow are very strong emotions, yet they are no match for fear when it comes to prodding most of us into taking preemptive actions, oftentimes against a nonexistent threat. A life motivated by fear is debilitated, sad, lonely, and wasted.

Thankfully, the princess has redeemed herself in the end when she chooses love. And good for her. While it seems like she has surrendered to Calàf, ultimately it is love that has conquered her and the prince is merely the vehicle of it. Just as the cruelty of one man against one woman has driven her into a perpetual mode of fear and unprovoked self-defense, one woman’s brave display of her Tennysonian philosophy[1] for the sake of one man has melted the icy walls around her heart. As much as Calàf wants to think that it is his kiss that does the trick, Liù’s silly yet courageous deed, I think, plays a much bigger role in Turandot’s transformation.

Speaking of Liù, who in their right mind falls in love with a guy and stays in that unconfessed, unrequited love all the way to their senseless death just because, “One day, in the palace, you smiled at me”? (Groan …) To quote John McEnroe, you cannot be serious. But what the cynical Leela fails/refuses to see the romantic Leela recognizes: when one sees oneself as unworthy, a smile — not only a form of recognition of one’s existence but also a sign of approval — from someone whom one deems worthy can drastically rock one’s world. When asked to identify herself, Liù answers, “Nulla sono.” Perceiving herself as “nothing,” the slave girl has spent her life quietly loving Calàf and faithfully serving King Timur in exile, and if she didn’t end up dying, she would have spent so many more years continuing to do both without getting anything back. Silly? Perhaps. Noble? I guess. Brave? You bet.

The only character at whom both the cynical and the romantic parts of me shake their heads in mild exasperation is Calàf. Boy, does that douc-, uh, dude have issues. Just one glimpse of a rich, hot chick has him fall madly in lust. The reason? “Her perfume is in the air; it’s in my spirit.” (Banging head on the wall.) The joy of being reunited with his father, minutes before, is quickly replaced by the desire to win Turandot and her love. Does he care whether his ailing father has enough social security benefits to cover his living expense in the event he cannot solve the riddles and die? No. Does he feel a smidgen of guilt for leaving the responsibility of taking care of his father to poor Liù? No.[2]

Mr. recklessness and selfishness personified just stands there, a safe distance from sanity and prudence, singing his lungs out about how nobody is supposed to sleep and stuff. Why put other people’s lives in danger? Dude, you’ve solved the riddles; you’ve won the girl. Now quit singing, shut the heck up, and take her home. You both can duke it out over your issues later. That way nobody has to die. It’s mostly about lust and the desire to win at any costs not only the body of the object of lust but also the affection. Calàf is, in fact, more annoying than Turandot herself.

But is he entirely without any redemptive quality? Well, at least the prince is fair enough to give the royally ticked-off Turandot an “out” in the contract. Besides, let’s face it, if Calàf didn’t do so, we all wouldn’t have had a chance to enjoy one of the most beautiful songs ever written. Nessun Dorma can move to tears even those who don’t know one Italian word, those who aren’t into opera, and those who can’t put the song in the context of the story.

Heh. Maybe I’m reading too much into this. It’s just an opera, after all.

You can enjoy Turandot simply for what it is or you can make it complicated. You can look at Thai black or purple rice pudding with trepidation as something that’s so strange and difficult to figure out, or you can see it for what it is – nothing other than rice that has been cooked until it becomes a thick, sticky goo then seasoned to taste. Once you come to see it in that way, rice pudding, Thai or otherwise, isn’t really all that intimidating or mysterious. In other words, just make rice and make sure it’s extra wet. Then season to taste. Yet, this dessert ranks among the top five of the Thai recipes requested by my readers.

There is no recipe. Really. All you have to do is boil 1 part rice with 5 parts water for 30 minutes. Then you turn off the heat and let the rice swell and fully absorb all the liquid in the covered pot for about 30-60 minutes depending on the size of the batch. During that process, the tough and chewy outer layers of the unpolished rice kernels will be broken down, allowing the starch to be released. The end result is a gooey body of rice that is very soft, yet so thick you can stand a wooden spoon in it.

Now, the cooking time (30 minutes) applies to new crop rice which is what you get from the store most of the time. The longer the rice has sat in your pantry, the less moisture it has and the longer it will take to cook the same amount of rice. The only fool-proof way is to start out with 30 minutes, let the rice swell off the heat for 30-60 minutes, and cook it some more if the kernels are still hard.

Then you sweeten it with sugar. How much sugar? Keep adding until it’s sweet enough for you. The sugar will also provide additional moisture to the rice and thin out the thick goo somewhat. Once all that is done, you spoon the finished rice pudding into a serving cup or bowl, and top it with a dollop of lightly-salted coconut cream. That’s pretty much it. This dessert is so ridiculously easy to make that I’m almost embarrassed to blog about it.

But if you have a knack for complicating things like I do, here is a list of things that you may want to keep in mind:

* Start off by making sure you are using the right kind of rice. Sometimes, people confuse the black/purple sticky rice used in Southeast Asian cuisine with the short-grain black pearl rice (forbidden rice) mostly used in East Asia. They are two different kinds of rice. The picture below should help guide you in finding the right kind of rice at your local Asian grocery store. You can also print out this: ข้าวเหนียวดำ and hand it to the people at the store if they speak Thai.

* Do not season the rice until it has fully absorbed the water and become soft and gooey. Adding sugar prematurely causes the kernels to “seize” and refuse to burst open. Your rice pudding will be a watery, runny mess of rice that is too al dente to be considered good rice pudding. Hold off on all flavoring agents until all of the kernels have been softened and broken down.

* Add sugar to the softened rice while it’s still warm so that the sugar will be completely dissolved.

  • I always add a bit of salt to my desserts as unsalted or under-salted desserts, to me, are cloyingly sweet and lack flavor dimension. In this case, though, I do not salt the rice pudding proper. Instead I salt the indispensable coconut cream topping. (To make that, you mix one teaspoon of salt into every 3/4 cup of the creamy part (aka the “head”) of the coconut milk which you use. If you use canned coconut milk, this will be the thick part that rises to the top when the can has stood undisturbed for some time at low temperature.)

    * As you eat the pudding, gradually stir the mildly salty coconut cream topping into the rice pudding. The creaminess and the saltiness of the topping will balance out the sweetness and the starchiness of the pudding, resulting in every single bite being perfectly-seasoned and with just right consistency.

    * This is the reason I (and, from what I’ve noticed, most street vendors in Thailand) prefer to keep the pudding and the topping separate as this works best in preserving the desired consistency of the pudding. Most recipes which you have perhaps seen tell you to add the coconut milk right into the pudding. While that can be done, I have found that the presence of the coconut milk in the pudding undermines the thickening power of the starch released by the rice. Within minutes, you’ll notice that your rice pudding will lose its much-desired viscosity and become watery. Without the coconut milk mixed in, your rice pudding will stay gooey and thick for days, refrigerated or not.

    * Lastly, it is worth noting that the most common designation for this type of rice, at least in Southeast Asia, is “black sticky (or glutinous) rice.” Strictly speaking, it’s not really black, though; it’s dark purple. That’s why you sometimes hear it called purple sticky rice. Often finding myself in a quandary, I usually refer to both colors. Just be informed that they are one and the same since there doesn’t seem to be a standardized designation.

    Heck, even opera gurus can’t decide whether the final T in the name Turandot is supposed to be mute French-style or vocal to reflect its Persian etymology. As it turns out, Turandot and black/purple rice pudding have more in common than I’d thought.


    1 Tis better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all – Lord Alfred Tennyson (1809-1892)

    2 “… Don’t weep, Liù. If one far-off day, I smiled at you, then for that smile, my sweet girl, listen to me: your master tomorrow will be perhaps alone in the world. Don’t leave him! Take him away with you! …” and “… Soften for him the road to exile! O my poor Liù, this, this is what he who smiles no more asks of your unfailing heart… he who smiles no more! …” What. A. Piece. Of. Work.

  • 33 Responses to Thai Black, Purple Rice Pudding with Coconut Cream Topping and Turandot

    1. Cucinista November 22, 2009 at 10:30 pm #

      Wonderful precis of Turandot. What I love about Puccini is that dualism of his, as though he couldn’t make up his mind whether he was a serious artiste or having fun, whether the audience could follow him or if he had to sweep them along with his arias kicking and screaming. As much as I abhor sentimentalism in almost all other genres, I weep copiously at all the appropriate moments in his works.

      And on to more important things: thank you for the pudding recipe. I think I’ll keep it up my sleeve in case I ever have a black and white dinner…

    2. doggybloggy November 23, 2009 at 1:30 am #

      this looks so gooey gooey good!

    3. Anonymous November 23, 2009 at 8:51 pm #

      I love your blog. The pictures are so good and the instructions are precise. Thank you for taking the time to let us all know of more delicious Thai recipes.

    4. lisaiscooking November 23, 2009 at 9:41 pm #

      Sounds simply lovely. And, I found Thai purple rice at our Whole Foods the other day!

    5. JennShaggy November 23, 2009 at 11:14 pm #

      Thank you so much! I’d love to take place in the battle, but I’m a busy little bee trying to wrap up my cookbook right now. I wish I had the time.

      Gosh your photography is gorgeous. Hopefully I can partake next month!

    6. Juliana November 24, 2009 at 12:32 am #

      I still remember when I first saw Turandot…absolutely touching…
      I had this rice in restaurant, but never made at home…looks yummie!

    7. Arwen from Hoglet K November 24, 2009 at 3:45 am #

      The pudding still sounds simpler than the characters in the opera – even after you add the complications to the recipe. I guess if the characters can annoy you that much they really are interesting.

    8. The Duo Dishes November 24, 2009 at 11:29 pm #

      You can find the connection in almost anything. That’s a good thing of course. Another recipe to try! Does the list ever get shorter?

    9. 5 Star Foodie November 24, 2009 at 11:29 pm #

      I’ve never gone to see Turandot, hope to see it someday soon & take my daughter, she’s recently getting into opera. The rice pudding looks totally scrumptious!

    10. Sassy Critic November 25, 2009 at 1:14 am #

      I love this post. Immediately I thought of a cranberry sauce analogy. Same mystery surrounding the stuff, yet embarrassingly easy. Boil and add sugar. Allow to cool. Presto!

      You have a unique talent with juxtaposition.

      P.S. I have to admit, I loved listening to the Puccini while reading about rice.

    11. Anonymous November 25, 2009 at 3:24 pm #

      Haha, I agree with the person who said you had a talent with juxtaposition.

      I’m one of the people who think this rice pudding is complicated, but I promise to give it a try. You’ve made it seem so easy. I’m putting myself on a challenge to make one new Thai dish a month.

      Here’s a challenge for YOU, Gorgeous. I’m a fighter pilot and I challenge you to write a post connecting pilots with a Thai dish. Let’s see if you can do that.


    12. MaryMoh November 26, 2009 at 9:01 am #

      I love this black rice desserts. Used to eat a lot when I was back home. I have just bought a packet of this rice the other day. Will wait when there are more people at home to cook this. It’s fun to eat together.

    13. Erica November 26, 2009 at 2:39 pm #

      I love rice pudding! That sounds interesting and delicious! I have to try this one soon 🙂

    14. Manggy November 28, 2009 at 5:46 am #

      I’m not an opera fan (and in fact have never seen one), so you might say you spoiled that one for me, hehe 🙂 But I did enjoy the analysis!
      Don’t be embarrassed to blog this because of the process- the product is quite beautiful 🙂

    15. OysterCulture November 29, 2009 at 2:49 pm #

      What a fun read, and this rice pudding looks to be the perfect topper for a nice meal, or simply a lovely treat on its own. You do not have to decide, whatever your mood or inclination, its up for the challenge.

    16. s. stockwell December 8, 2009 at 2:21 am #

      This is so interesting? Could make a beautiful artful dish? love this post. best from Montecito, s

    17. Tasty Eats At Home December 8, 2009 at 3:57 pm #

      Looks delicious! I have some purple rice in my pantry – will need to make this ASAP!

    18. Jessie December 10, 2009 at 1:48 am #

      very interesting recipe, I have learned a lot about turnadot from your post.

    19. Anonymous May 13, 2010 at 4:59 pm #

      Thanks for the post, I love reading your site, and check it for updates almost daily!
      As for this rice dish, I bought the correct rice and I cooked it for the 15 minutes (1 part rice with 5 parts water). But, even after over 60 minutes of letting it sit it was a watery mess… Are you calling for too much water, or am I doing something wrong?

    20. Leela May 14, 2010 at 1:00 pm #

      Anonymous – Sorry about your comment not showing up sooner. Blogger went crazy yesterday. And when the comment hadn’t shown up, it felt weird to answer an invisible question. 🙂

      Well, let’s see.

      Assuming you have the correct rice and didn’t add salt or sugar to the rice while it was boiling, my only theory is that you’ve been blessed with an extra new crop of rice which has higher moisture content than old crops. It happens sometimes, but more commonly with jasmine rice.

      The 1:5 ratio for black sticky rice pudding is pretty standard. Sometimes, you see recipes that suggest somewhere between 1:2.5 to 1:3, but in those cases you’re required to let the rice soak in water overnight or at least for 4-5 hours. With a lot of water being absorbed, the actual rice:water at the time of cooking is lower. I don’t soak the rice (no other reasons other than that 99% of the time it’s unplanned) so I use more water.

      The other reason may be due to larger amounts of rice? Sometimes, if you cook more than 3-4 cups of rice in a big, tall pot, you’re going to need more than 15 minutes of cooking. I’ll make that note to the instructions. Now that I think about it, I’ve never cooked more than 1.5-2 cups of rice at a time.

      Hope you didn’t throw it out. When that happens, just continue to boil the rice, hard, some more — another 15-20 minutes (??). It’s the time issue, not the ratio issue.

      Thanks for reporting back. I’ll add this to the post. 🙂

    21. Katherine February 5, 2011 at 5:08 am #

      Hi! I tried making this delicious looking pudding tonight, with some success and some failure – the flavors are wonderful and everything tastes good, but mine too turned out a little water-y. I’m wondering if it was because I soaked it for an hour and a half or so beforehand, which you mentioned might cause the problem? I already added the sugar after an hour of letting it sit covered, off the heat, but my question is – after adding the sugar, can I still boil it/heat it longer to get it a little more glutinous and a little less watery? Thanks!

    22. Leela February 5, 2011 at 1:59 pm #

      Katherine – You can, but it’s best to add the sugar after the rice has fully released it’s starch and become thick. Old crop rice or rice that has been stored for a long time has less moisture than new crop rice or just-harvested rice, and I have a feeling that’s what you have. In this case, after boiling the rice and letting it sit, it’s important to do a spoon check. If the rice hasn’t fully expanded or gotten thick enough so that you can stand a spoon in it, boil it some more and let it sit again until it passes the spoon test. Only then should the sugar be added.

      With the batch you made, I think it can still be saved. Try boiling the whole thing some more, uncovered (to aid evaporation). The kernels may not burst open as much, and they may have the texture of cooked wild rice, but at least you’ll get some of the moisture out.

    23. roohbaroo November 8, 2011 at 2:07 am #

      hi! thanks so much for the detailed instructions. i saved this link months ago and finally gave it a try tonight. i had some of the same trouble as a couple of the other commenters – still watery after the prescribed time – so i kept boiling it until it became thicker and then let it sit until the “spoon test” came out right. exciting! but… then i added agave syrup (instead of sugar), let it cool a while, came back after half an hour and it was watery again! frustrating! is it because of using agave instead of sugar? i didn’t have any sugar in the house and didn’t think it would matter. can’t imagine why else it changed like that.

    24. Admin November 8, 2011 at 2:40 pm #

      Roohbaroo – Hmm. This is good to know. Thank you for the report.

      The immediate answer is, I don’t know. Sugar does affect the gelatinization of starch; that’s why it’s best to add sugar to this particular recipe towards the end. There may be something about agave nectar that makes the problem worse.

      Given the fact that, unlike granulated sugar, agave nectar does not need to be dissolved with heat and can be stirred right into anything at any temperature, if you insist on using it (and nothing wrong with that), you may want to experiment with adding the syrup to the rice pudding after it has completely cooled down.

      I’m thinking this may work, though it’s merely a guess.

    25. roohbaroo November 8, 2011 at 6:52 pm #

      thanks much! i’ll definitely try sugar next time i make it – this time i just happened to be out. you’re right that this is a simple method, but it is capricious, too!

    26. Melissa M. May 22, 2012 at 8:32 pm #

      Love your site. You are a great writer. You are doing a great service for mankind. Thank you.

    27. Admin May 23, 2012 at 2:32 am #

      Melissa – You’re too, too darned kind. Thank you.

    28. sivvy lization July 17, 2012 at 2:15 am #

      i was introduced to thai desserts in a cooking class some time back.your recipes and explanations are are a great help.thanks loads 🙂

      Can’t wait to try this one out

    29. Arash Jacob September 22, 2012 at 2:15 am #

      Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge. It is appreciated. I will soon try this, just as soon as I head back to Thai town for the black glutinous rice I did not buy the first time. Also, thanks for the splatter guard method to cook regular sticky rice. I just tried the bamboo and aluminum steamer method and wasn’t sure how to clean the bamboo steamer. Now I know, and agreed–it sounds like a chore. Thanks again and may you have a lovely peacefulness in the kitchen!

    30. Kylene August 29, 2013 at 11:53 am #

      I love your site … for two very different reasons.

      1) I lived in Thailand while serving in the Peace Corps and learned some basic cooking methods while I was there. I posted about it while overseas and have off and on continued a Thai cooking blog since coming home. I love trying new things in the kitchen and am constantly scouring the web for new recipes to try. I must say, your site is my “go to” for all my recipe needs. I have never had a recipe NOT turn out. Very explanatory, straight forward, and easy to follow.

      2) I am an English nut (used to be an English teacher) and adore your style of writing. I love that you pull real life into your posts and rather than just throwing a recipe together, connect it with something entirely unrelated but completely consuming and interesting.

      I’ll keep coming back time and time again … and as for this recipe, I’m throwing a Thai dinner party tonight and needed a dessert. I’ll report back and let you know how it goegs!

      • Leela August 29, 2013 at 12:08 pm #

        Truly appreciate it, Kylene.


    1. Nang Led, Khao Tan: Thai Sweet Crispy Rice Cakes with Cane Sugar Drizzle (ขนมนางเล็ด ข้าวแต๋น) | SheSimmers - September 24, 2012

      […] well.Q: Oh, back to the rice thing — can I use the sticky black/purple rice you use to make black/purple rice pudding?A: Yes, by all means. You’re going to have to be more vigilant when frying the purple rice […]

    2. Turquoise's NEW journal: rants and raves of gelatin and law school - Page 733 | Mark's Daily Apple Health and Fitness Forum page 733 - June 18, 2015

      […] likely eat it all. …this recipe just makes me want to buy a 10 lb bag of black glutinous rice: Thai Black Purple Rice Pudding with Coconut Cream Topping and Turandot JOURNAL. Gelatin/bone broth recipes blog. (Latest recipe: Paleo Truffles, No-Bake Pumpkin Pie) […]