It seems silly to be growing herbs primarily in order to harvest their roots instead of berries, leaves, blossoms, or shoots. But if you’re a serious Thai cook who lives in the United States (or a chef in charge of the Thai menu at one of the world’s hardest restaurants to get into), you know why: supermarket cilantro/coriander comes emasculated. It has been decided on our behalf and without our consent that the roots — the part that we desire as much as the others — are not to be kept. Whatever the reason(s) might be, this is sad and frustrating.
If you’re one of those who live in the areas where cilantro roots are available to you any time, we rejoice with you. Not only do you have at your disposal one of the essential ingredients in Thai cooking, you also enjoy the fact that your cilantro — with all the roots attached — stay fresh longer in the refrigerator.
Not being so fortunate, some of us have to take matters into our own hands.
Sure, the stems are a handy substitute. But the stems aren’t as potent as the roots, and you often need to double the amount of stems in order to replicate the flavor and aroma of the roots. In some recipes where you just want the flavor and not so much the roughage bulk (which could burn on the grill or turn an otherwise smooth sauce into a thin vegetable puree), having to use a lot of cilantro stems could be problematic. Also — not the worst thing in the world, of course — when it comes to some dishes where presentation kind of matters, the green color of the stems could mar the final appearance. The off-white roots don’t present this problem.
Personally, though, it’s more about getting back a sense of control. I dedicate 5-6 weeks during the warmer months in a year growing coriander just to collect as many roots as I can to use the rest of the year. Having cilantro roots handy is the main reason, but I’m not going to hide the fact that this is also done as a way of saying, “forget you,” to rootless coriander, sitting pretty, all trimmed and everything, on the supermarket shelf.
[Disclaimer: My brown thumb keeps me from having the gall to consider myself even a hobby horticulturalist. And the following instructions work best for those who want to grow cilantro with the primary intention of harvesting their roots.]
You start out with the highest quality coriander/cilantro seeds you can find. Soak them in water for 24-36 hours before planting them just to soften the outer shells of the seeds. Then fill a wide container with drainage holes, which is about a foot high, 3/4 of the way with potting soil. Scatter the seeds all over the surface of the soil.
Place the container somewhere where there’s at least some sunlight. It doesn’t have to be in full sun all the time (in fact, extreme heat could cause the plants to go to seed prematurely). You can place the container on a windowsill inside the house.
Within 48 hours, you’ll start to see some growth. There’s no need to do anything at this point other than keeping the soil somewhat moist (but not soaking wet).
In 7-10 days, you’ll see this.
As you can see, the plants are so crowded together which usually wouldn’t be an ideal situation. But since we really don’t care about what grows upwards above the ground as much as we do what grows downwards below the ground, let it be.
The quality of the seeds, the quality of the potting soil, the nutrients that may have been added to it, the amount of water, and the amount of sunlight all play a role in how fast and how well your cilantro grows. In general, it takes 30-40 days post-germination for the roots to be mature enough for harvest. Sometimes, it takes 50-60 days. Don’t go by the number of days; go by the size of the roots instead.
But how can one measure the size of something that grows underground? After all, cilantro hates being transplanted and will drop dead on you if you pull one out of the ground and try to replant it. Well, here’s the method that I use to gauge the size of the roots.
By the time the plants hit the 30-day mark, they will have developed one or two larger stems. Roots that are mature enough to use (and not too mature to the point of being woody and tough) are about 3.5 inches in length. With the roots invisible, our only clue is the size of the largest stem. Based on my observation, when the largest stem measures 15-16 millimeters in circumference (which means its diameter is about 5 millimeters), the length of the roots which are attached to it will also measure between 3-4 inches. And that falls within the desired range.
If the large stems still don’t measure 15-16 millimeters in circumference, let the coriander continue to grow for another while. You can trim off the leaves and use those in your cooking, but leave the larger stems (you need them to gauge the root growth) and roots alone.
All you have to do is cut off the roots leaving about half an inch of the stems attached, and soak them in room temperature water for 5-6 minutes just to loosen up the dirt on the roots. Then wash them once more under running water to make sure they’re immaculately clean, blot them dry with a kitchen towel, wrap them in two layers of dry paper towel, place them in a freezer bag, and freeze them to use later in the year. (The roots can also be stored the same way in the fridge for about a week. But since freezing doesn’t seem to alter the texture and aroma of cilantro roots very much, I usually just freeze them.)